Colm: ...this [Nervana] is an expensive device...
Demo: Dr. Komisaruk’s is $5,000!
Hi Demo,
I think the reason for a Dr. K $5K VNS price point would as you know, just like the Feinstein institute device for arthritis, be related to those devices actually targeting specific Immune bio markers.
A General VNS stimulating device possibly just influences the nervous system and the parasympathetic nerves, in so as far as I can gather and understand.
Am open to correction as I’m not an expert.
Regards,
Colm
Colm, do you think it could be eventually worthwhile for POISCenter to raise $5,000 to experiment with a more targeted device, perhaps in tandem with what the new research team might find in the way of autonomic, endocrine and immune mediators of POIS?
Hi Demo,
Sorry for taking time to get back to this.
I think that further VNS testing with
a more targeted VNS device is worth experimenting with. If an extra $5K was being raised, there is potential benefits in seeing where that is best spent, be it building upon the new NORD funded study, or else as a separate sub study. Several studies need to be evaluated and this could be one of them.
It makes most sense IMHO to be patient and see what the focus of the new study is entitled and what proposition is being focused on.
If I recall correctly, the original study that did not run its course was entitled “Is POIS a case of Vagal Dystonia”. Based on his evaluation of the forums RFP and forum outline content back then he felt Vagus nerve could be implicated.
As Dr. K was an orgasm expert and had zeroed in on the Vagus Nerve influences in POIS, it certainly makes sense not to forget the possibilities. Dystonia however can’t easily be seen as part of all the POIS types.
One of the suggested treatments for dystonia is electrical stimulation of the auricular branch of the vagus nerve, in studies seen as being potentially effective.
Using (in a committed manner), an appropriate VNS device as a minimally invasive treatment for dystonia, could obviously help a person with Dystonia. This download here speaks about the technical aspects in using an Auricular approach to Vagus Nerve stimulation, with the condition of dystonia.
https://www.degruyter.com/downloadpdf/j/bmte.2013.58.issue-s1-A/bmt-2013-4033/bmt-2013-4033.pdfAll the best,
Colm